People, Policies & Power · By Rosey Singh

“Okay. What happened?”

That’s usually the first thing I ask when a manager wants to fire someone for poor performance, and I’ve just read the glowing review they wrote two months earlier.

I pull up the review and read it back to them.

“You said they were meeting expectations here. You praised their work here. Walk me through how we got from that conversation to this one.”

Sometimes something really did change. A performance review captures a moment in time. But the answer that makes me stop is this one.

“This has been going on for months. I told them. I just didn’t want to put it in writing.”

Okay. When did you tell them? What did you say? What did you ask them to do differently? What happened when you followed up?

Because I’ve heard the employee’s side, too.

“But my review was great. I don’t understand what I did wrong.”

When I read the review, I could see why they’re confused.

You remember giving feedback. They remember being told they were doing well.

Two people can walk out of the same conversation with very different impressions. A manager might think, I made it clear that the late reports were a problem. The employee might think, We talked about one report running late. My review says I’m doing well overall.

If I’m in HR trying to understand why we’re suddenly talking about termination, that difference matters. What was the employee told? How clearly was it said? Did they know what needed to change? And did their manager give them a chance to do something about it?

A glowing review alongside months of undocumented concerns makes those questions harder to answer. And by the time HR is piecing it together, the manager may already have made up their mind.

Being nice in December can be pretty unfair in February.

I get why managers do this. They like the person. They don’t want to discourage them. They don’t know how to say, “I enjoy working with you, and I need you to deliver more consistently.”

So they write about everything that’s going well and gloss over what’s bothering them. Then another deadline slips in February and they say, “I’m done. I’ve been dealing with this for months.”

Maybe you have been dealing with it for months. How long has the employee known you needed them to fix it?

There’s a difference between how long you’ve been frustrated and how long someone’s had a fair chance to improve. If you’re asking to fire someone over an ongoing performance issue, that difference is one of the first things I want to understand.

Put something in the review they can actually use.

If you’ve already raised the concern, go back through your notes. When did you discuss it? What example did you give? What did you agree would happen next?

If this is the first time you’re being direct about it, own that. You can say, “I should have been clearer about this sooner. Here’s what I’m seeing, and here’s what I need from you going forward.”

And then get specific. “Be more accountable” gives someone very little to work with. Try this instead.

“Two of the last three reports came in after the deadline, which delayed the team’s handoff. For the next month, I need the report by noon on Thursday. If you’re waiting on numbers from another team, flag it by Wednesday and I’ll help you get what you need. Let’s check in after the next two reports to see how it’s going.”

Write down what you discussed. Share the recap. Then show up for the check-in you put on the calendar.

Give people credit for what they do well, too. If someone is great with clients and keeps missing internal deadlines, both things belong in the review. That’s an honest assessment, and it gives the employee a clearer picture of what to keep doing and where to improve.

You’re paid to manage. That means paying attention to the work, giving feedback while there’s time to act on it, and helping people improve. If you skip that work and go straight to asking HR to fire someone, you’re holding them to a standard you haven’t held yourself to.


If HR first hears about a performance problem when a manager asks to fire someone, it’s time to look at how your managers handle performance.

I’m Rosey Singh, founder of Eunoia Collective. We provide senior fractional HR leadership to growing businesses, with particular expertise in staffing and recruitment. I work directly with owners, COOs, and their HR teams to spot workforce risks early and help managers handle performance issues while there’s still time to address them.

That might mean reviewing what your managers write in performance reviews, setting a shared standard for documenting feedback and follow-up, or coaching a manager through a conversation they’ve been putting off. When a difficult employee decision reaches your desk, I help you sort through what happened, what was communicated, and what you need to know before deciding how to proceed.

If you’ve had to ask, “How am I only hearing about this now?” bring one example to a free strategy call. We’ll talk through where things broke down and what I’d tackle first with your team.

Book a free strategy call with Rosey